Diamond Card Talk Member
| Why is this not even on RA's website? I'm guessing they gave up on a traditional product for this niche series and I don't necessarily disagree with them, but the lack of notice is surprising. Every other pack out of the 300 has a MacFarlane autograph card. This will sell out I'm sure, but it will be worth it only for the 150 packs that have his card in my opinion. |
| |
Diamond Card Talk Member
| Oh geez, never thought I'd hear this at RA, and with the single autograph card that makes this whole product attractive. If the scans are truly from 3 different cards, they look to be identical. That would be a big problem indeed!
And the questions have already begun to hit RA's website. |
| |
Gold Card Talk Member
| A different seller on eBay also has an identical signature on their McFarlane card. Can’t believe RA let autopens of a signer this big get through! Did they not even look at the cards? What a balls up. |
| |
Diamond Card Talk Member
| quote: Originally posted by ravenheart: Yeah, just compared several listings on eBay, and although the placement of the signature isn't always exactly the same, the signature itself definitely is.
A few were up last night on eBay asking in the $400 - $600 range. A couple are still now and at least one sold for $250. What happens with the card value will depend very much on whether or not RA can provide authentic replacements for anyone holding autopenned signatures. The back of the card would appear to put the responsibility of authenticity upon the signer, but of course that would never hold up in the court of public opinion. RA has little excuse for not seeing it before packing and they will have to do something to compensate first line buyers, if the situation is really as it looks now. |
| |
Platinum Card Talk Member
| quote: Originally posted by Logan: I can't believe a manufacturer would not check signatures that come in for autopens. That's the first thing I would do and it would take about 10 seconds.
In Rittenehouse's defense this isn't the first time Seth has signed, and his first set of signatures for them seemed perfectly fine. . . I can see how the second batch doesn't get as scrutinized. I'm sure Rittenhouse is more bothered about this than anyone else. . . |
| Posts: 5484 | Location: Parts Unknown. | Registered: January 25, 2001 |
IP
|
|
Diamond Card Talk Member
| So just saw this on the description page from a seller with one of the current eBay auctions running . . . "The manufacturer has informed us to hold off on the Seth MacFarlene autograph card due to authenticity claims. This card will not ship until a solution is identified by the manufacturer." So RA is at least acting fast. Even though it was a massive shrew up on their part, I'm sure they have too much to lose not to try to correct it. And let's not forget that MacFarlene or MacFarlene's representatives also allowed an "authorized fake" to be submitted to fulfill a paid autograph contract. So how disrespectfully is that to RA and to all the card collectors and all his fans? |
| |
Diamond Card Talk Member
| Apparently Steve Charendoff over at RA has just confirmed the autopenned MacFarlene signatures and said they are working on a solution and appreciate understanding and patience. So good for his honesty, its unfortunate for all concerned. |
| |
Platinum Card Talk Member
| Seth did this garbage on his last book too. Everyone sold as a signed copy was autopen. Kind of glad I have never been much of a fan and have not had any desire to chase his signature. ____________________ Just because it's rare doesn't mean it's valuable.
|
| Posts: 5005 | Location: Tennessee | Registered: March 09, 2002 |
IP
|
|
Diamond Card Talk Member
| While some eBay sellers have put the MacFarlene autopenned card on hold, others are urging buyers to get them while they can because they may be recalled. I love this hobby. |
| |
Gold Card Talk Member
| The Jason Alexander card A25 is 1 per 6 packs, only 50 made. |
| |
NSU Elf
| quote: Originally posted by Tommy C: The Jason Alexander card A25 is 1 per 6 packs, only 50 made.
Where are the odds listed? |
| Posts: 829 | Location: Southern New Jersey | Registered: April 03, 2010 |
IP
|
|
Diamond Card Talk Member
| quote: Originally posted by ifish73:
Where are the odds listed?
Someone just posted that there were 50 cards made for Alexander on RA's message board. No idea where that data came from. You know the Orville Archives Autograph Card Edition is not even listed as a product on their website. Go explain that? And it was barely offered, I guess maybe because of the limited number of packs, but the whole product just seemed slapped together with radio silence. Not like RA's usual release routine. |
| |
Platinum Card Talk Member
| I was told it wasn't being offered on the website because it was likely sold out to wholesale, who they can allocate if necessary unlike a retail purchase. I imagine the details will be posted eventually, probably not until the solution to the current situation is in place. Ed |
| Posts: 5127 | Location: Phoenix, AZ | Registered: March 09, 2003 |
IP
|
|