It appears that Inkworks' new X-Files set, coming in late July, will have some impossible to find chase cards.
For every 3 cases ordered, a dealer will receive 1 of 2 Pieceworks cards, numbered PW14A and 14B. One is of Mulder's coat, the other is Scully's. So, in other words, a dealer will have to order SIX cases to get them both. It appears that they are both being produced in equal numbers.
As if that wasn't enough, for every TEN cases ordered, a dealer will get an exclusive Mulder/Scully double autograph card, signed by both stars.
I have every single X-Files set Inkworks has done to date, but b/c of this I'm going to pass on this one. There's no way a collector can reasonably obtain these incentives. What do other people think ? How many dealers will actually have the duo auto for sale ?
Posts: 4835 | Location: Bayonne, NJ, USA | Registered: May 06, 2001
Once again a set comes out where the best card will not be in the packs. I keep saying it but it is becoming less about collecting and more about buying every day.
____________________ Come, it is time for you to keep your appointment with The Wicker Man.
Posts: 29067 | Location: wolverhampton staffs uk | Registered: July 19, 2002
Shame on all card companies that make the best(any) card(s) not pack inserted.
If you have to sink to that level to sell your cards then please, at least pack insert half or more. Its just the polite thing to do. It really hurts to have your balls squeezed that hard!
Posts: 168 | Location: Portland | Registered: February 01, 2008
I can't believe what's going on here again. I don't really want to go manufacturer or dealer bashing, but the guy in the street is not really being thought about any more.
There are threads on this site which indicate that people are leaving the hobby at the rate of knots. Guys, news about new releases like this just isn't helping. Go figure!!
Posts: 1776 | Location: Wales, UK | Registered: June 10, 2005
I am actually quite upset about this. As I mentioned, I have all of the X-Files cards that Inkworks and Topps previously produced, with complete runs of chase cards on each.
Now this happens. I'm sorry, but I won't go after a set if I'm going to have holes in it. This is a real disservice to the collector !
Even if we could find these chase cards, do the companies think it's fun for us to have to spend thousands of dollars on a single card ? It's not fun, it's frustrating !
Posts: 4835 | Location: Bayonne, NJ, USA | Registered: May 06, 2001
Are there dealers out there who will carry such a volume of product like this ? I am not asking people for names, or to recommend anyone.
As I mentioned, you need 3 cases to get 1 Pieceworks, 6 cases to get the 2nd, and 10 cases to get the auto. I am asking this out of curiosity. Are there people out there who will buy 3, 6 or 10 cases of cards ?
And if so, it seems that these cards will be reserved for people with an "in" with the dealer. The rest of us are out of luck.
Posts: 4835 | Location: Bayonne, NJ, USA | Registered: May 06, 2001
I think everyone who complains here, should think about sets like Star Wars 30th Ann., Indiana Jones Heritage, Indiana Jones KOTCS, Donruss, Star Trek TOS 40th Ann. 1, ... All these sets contained cards that are way harder to get, than the Mulder/Scully dual auto. I'm speaking here of cards like the Harrison Ford/ George Lucas / Spielberg autos, the Gene Roddenberry cut auto (25 produced), 1/1 cut autos, the Labeouf/Allen dual auto (only 1 exists),... Is a 10 case card nice for collectors: hell, no. I hate multi case incentives. But only because there is a multi case card, it won't stop me buying a product I like. I'm also a completist. But hey, you can't have everything that's out there. Unfortunately.
____________________ "I am the beginning;the end;the one who is many. I am the borg...I am the collective." Borg Queen in Star Trek: First Contact
Originally posted by Cee_Jay: I think everyone who complains here, should think about sets like Star Wars 30th Ann., Indiana Jones Heritage, Indiana Jones KOTCS, Donruss, Star Trek TOS 40th Ann. 1, ... All these sets contained cards that are way harder to get, than the Mulder/Scully dual auto. I'm speaking here of cards like the Harrison Ford/ George Lucas / Spielberg autos, the Gene Roddenberry cut auto (25 produced), 1/1 cut autos, the Labeouf/Allen dual auto (only 1 exists),... Is a 10 case card nice for collectors: hell, no. I hate multi case incentives. But only because there is a multi case card, it won't stop me buying a product I like. I'm also a completist. But hey, you can't have everything that's out there. Unfortunately.
Just ask yourself why both Indy releases are selling for $37 a box. High level cards that are impossible to get that are required to complete the set are not cool. It seems the Non-sport industry has decided to go the same way as sports with the same result. Why can't people learn from previous mistakes. It's as if it doesn't apply to them.
Posts: 1776 | Location: Wales, UK | Registered: June 10, 2005
Topps products are currently selling for what they are, due to the lack of inconsistent packaging and the fact that people are turned off by the inclusion of certain artists in those products.
As much badmouthing as Topps has received recently at least they can say that a collector has a chance, albeit a very slim one to pull any card in their products.
Last year, I bemoaned dealer incentives to Steve Charendoff (Rittenhouse) and how the ordinary collector was being screwed. In a very round-about way, he said the collectors loved them and they are always in demand. Inkworks have jumped on an increasingly large band wagon. the amount of cases needed to complete a set has reached extremes that will make collectors leave the hobby in droves. The manufacturers need to wake up and remember the core business - us. I have always believed that incentives are a product of two things - greed and potential bad sellers.
Posts: 3804 | Location: United Kingdom | Registered: April 21, 2004
Lol I complained about the FOA promos for Supernatural and they are one of the most expensive cards in the set but I got SLAMMED for that saying that they are a good idea..
there is NO difference between those and these, the response will be the same check ebay.. The only difference is dealers will actually have to buy something to get these...
____________________ Ignore list Batman, Headless
Posts: 3874 | Location: Pennsylvania | Registered: January 29, 2005
Originally posted by Jim Streich: Lol I complained about the FOA promos for Supernatural and they are one of the most expensive cards in the set but I got SLAMMED for that saying that they are a good idea..
there is NO difference between those and these, the response will be the same check ebay.. The only difference is dealers will actually have to buy something to get these...
I think there is a slight difference between a FOA promo and a 10-case card, in terms of both the quantity produced and the price a collector would have to pay.
The two are incomparable in my mind.
Posts: 3137 | Location: England | Registered: June 23, 2005
Originally posted by David R: Are there dealers out there who will carry such a volume of product like this ? I am not asking people for names, or to recommend anyone.
Yes, I was speaking to a dealer recently to routinely orders 100 cases of product. They are out there, although this is an extreme example.
It wouldn't be too difficult for a dealer to get to a 10 case order, I mean if they can pre-sell 5-6 sealed cases, then sell a couple of cases worth of individual boxes, they are left with 2 cases to open, etc.
One thing I would like to point out is that it's the collectors who set the prices for these cards, so if everyone truly hates these so much they will be dirt cheap.
Jon
Posts: 5498 | Location: Parts Unknown. | Registered: January 25, 2001
Originally posted by Arvin Sloane: As much badmouthing as Topps has received recently at least they can say that a collector has a chance, albeit a very slim one to pull any card in their products.
The Jennifer Garner Elektra auto... collectors had only the secondary market to be able to get that card as it was only given to a few dealers as an incentive.
____________________ I'm a burning effigy of everything I used to be. Robbie Williams My Sketch Collection
Posts: 8466 | Location: Tormented Space | Registered: July 31, 2003
One of the advantage of these incentives going to dealers is that they are available to collectors. Let's say there's 50 of these cards made. If they were pack inserted, most of those would be retained by the collectors who pulled them. This would mean low supply on the secondary market and high prices. So, unless you are lucky enough to pull one, it's impossible to complete.
By going to dealers, all 50 are likely to hit the secondary market. I know it seems counterintuitive, but this actually reduces the prices on the ultra-rare cards. Yes, they are still expensive but not the thousands of dollars level.
Personally, I handle it by killing my completist tendencies. I just work out which cards I am going to collect and call that 'complete'. In fact, because the dealers can make money from the incentives, I believe I get lower prices on the boxes I do buy and it's actually cheaper for me to collect what I want.
Don't all flame me at once I just thought the other view might be useful for discussion.
Posts: 1574 | Location: temp UK, usually Australia | Registered: July 31, 2002
I just thought the other view might be useful for discussion.